The United Methodist Church: Divorce and Remarriage Comments

Responses to: The United Methodist Church: Divorce and Remarriage

14 Comments

  1. Gabriel Tupa says:

    No Biblical grounds exist for divorce (even in the case of adultery, abuse, or desertion) as God hates divorce and divorce is “legalized” unforgiveness. Check the two verses following the Lord’s prayer. Separation is permissible and reconciliation is necessary. Check verse about offering your gift. Just a lustful look is enough to commit adultery. Jesus in His Sermon on the Mount certainly wasn’t making it easier for couples to divorce. Marriage is binding and only death can separate what God has joined. Those who cause others to sin will be held accountable.

    • Gabriel, I’ll copy and paste my response below. I hope that it will be clear to you.
      _______________________

      No Biblical grounds exist for divorce (even in the case of adultery, abuse, or desertion) as God hates divorce and divorce is “legalized” unforgiveness.

      I understand what you are saying. And it does seem like unforgiveness would be involved. But let’s keep this in mind:
      1.We are to forgive when someone repents (Luke 17:3-4).

      2. I know that we may not understand the reasons involved, but Jesus did say that one who divorces his mate and marries another person commits adultery. But keep in mind that he gives the famous “exception” clause—“except for immorality” or “except for fornication.” Even if I don’t like this or understand it, Jesus our Lord did say it and we must accept it.

      Check the two verses following the Lord’s prayer.

      These are very important verses, aren’t they. But Matthew 6 must be combined with Luke 17:3-4 and others like that. Both the words and will of God the Father and Jesus Christ our Lord must be accepted.

      Separation is permissible and reconciliation is necessary. Check verse about offering your gift. Just a lustful look is enough to commit adultery. Jesus in His Sermon on the Mount certainly wasn’t making it easier for couples to divorce.

      Personally, I don’t know of anyone who would think or suggest that Jesus is speaking about “mental” adultery being a grounds for divorce and remarriage here. You don’t and I don’t.

      Marriage is binding and only death can separate what God has joined. Those who cause others to sin will be held accountable.

      This is definitely correct and we must keep this in mind.

      I do hold to a very conservative view on all of this. For instance, if someone remarries after an illegitimate divorce, then that person commits adultery and must stop committing this adultery and this relationship. While I know that some people who believe in the “no divorce” rule, they still allow a remarried and adulterous couple to remain I that state of adultery. I don’t. I’m not sure about you.
      Thanks so much for writing. I have been tempted to take the “no divorce” stance myself, yet the words of Christ are too important and His Lordship is so vital that I have thus far been unwilling to do this.

      May God lead us both into His will in this important matter.

  2. My sister and her husband were both divorced before they met each other. My sister’s husband was verbally abusive towards her and came close to physically abusing her when she decided she had to leave the marriage. They had young children and clearly her daughter and son did not need to see this abuse and my sister had very real fears that they could become the abuser or the victim when they married. She did not fight back due to what she witnessed in our parents’ marriage and it took counseling for her to come to this realization. She does bear guilt that had she not stood up to her husband, and possibly have made the marriage work.

    Today, she is happily married to an ordained pastor, who is also divorced. They both live the life that Jesus wants. They are active in their church, they minister others in need, they are faithful Christians. I do not need to expound on their true Christianity and their unwavering belief in God. Their children are both in happy marriages and have expressed to my sister that they are glad she divorced their father. I cannot believe that God will not welcome them both into His kingdom.

    • Hello Beth…

      Thank you so much for writing and sharing this difficult and painful part of your life—and especially your sister’s life. This subject often does bring to the fore quite painful parts of our past, ones that we generally want to forget.

      I can understand the reasoning that you give as to why your sister divorced her first husband. The way you described it, he must have been a seriously abusive husband. And I also assume that she didn’t have a Biblical “reason” to divorce—referring to adultery or fornication. You know the passages of Scripture (such as Matthew 5:31-32; 19:3-12; Mark 10:2-11; Luke 16:18; Romans 7:2-3; 1 Corinthians 7; etc.).

      As you probably are aware, I will not want to say that it is fine that she violated God’s Word in order to have a “good” second marriage. Although I would weep with you and with her for her past and her difficult circumstances, I wouldn’t want to condone something that Scripture would not condone. I do think that you understand why I say what I say.

      It is so hard to follow God’s Word when something looks so terrible (such as your sister’s first marriage) and something else looks so desirable (like her second marriage). Yet you probably know that we are called upon to do difficult things in life—since God knows far better than we do about marriage and divorce and remarriage and adultery.

      As for the “pastor” that she married, you didn’t say what church or denomination he was part of and whether his authorities agreed with him or not. Apart from the question of whether it was right for him to marry your sister, we know nothing about his own first marriage. Did he divorce his wife on the grounds of her unrepentant adultery? Or was there some other reason?
      May God always help you—and me—to look to His inspired, authoritative, and unerring Word in making decisions, even very difficult ones, in life.

      May God bless you.

      Richard

  3. Oh, by the way, we update our Book of Discipline every four years. Not sure when your article was written, but the BOD you reference is out of date by 7 quadrenium. If you want to advise people on what we believe it may be helpful to at least use current resources.

    • Yes, Susan, it may be good to invest in a later edition of your work. Just because the United Methodist Church was wrong in the past does not mean that it is wrong today–unless they are clinging to the same unscriptural practices.

      Thank you, Susan. I assume that the latest edition would be available online so I would not need to purchase this edition.

  4. Richard,
    We read the same Scriptures – we don’t see them the same.

    Interesting how in your view men make the interpretations and in so doing silence any alternate interpretations women may have as disobedience to God… makes me wonder how much that is God or male bias.

    God has clearly called me and many women in other denominations to full ordination. So maybe the real issue is not with us but with why God would do that.

    Guess I’m glad God has called me to pastor in a denomination where it’s okay to sit at a table with people who are divorced, who values all people as created equal, who believes every person sitting in the pew on Sunday morning is equally in need of God’s transforming grace, who wants their doors to be open to everyone, and celebrates an Open Table for communion. Guess God knew exactly what He was doing when He called me to ordination in the UMC and for that I am infinitely grateful.

    Again, I’d highly recommend the book I mentioned… if girls are allowed to recommend books to men.

    • Hello again Susan….

      I hope that you will come to see that my response has anything to do with the worth of any individual. God loves us all and all may find forgiveness from Him in Christ.

      The point is that God has spoken and if we respect Him and His Word, we must be willing to comply with it. If we don’t, we make ourselves a Judge over God–the very one who will be our Judge!

      If God has revealed that remarriage and adultery is against His will and constitutes adultery, and that all unrepentant adulterers will not inherit the Kingdom of God (1 Corinthians 6:9-10; cf. Galatians 5:19-21), then we must accept it whether we like it or not. God has spoken and this is sufficient for the one wo reveres God’s authority over us.

      As to women’s role in the body of Christ in a public capacity, it is not you nor is it me who has the right to object to this. God is the only one who can tell us what His mind is–and He has done this very thing. When God limits a woman’s participation, we must know that God knows more than we do. Regardless of what a human denomination (such as the United Methodist Church)may allow or promote, still we are subject to God.

      If we are humble, God’s will is what we want. In your case, God can forgive your public rejection of His authority and your willingness to refuse to be subject to His will. Women’s insubordination or insubjection is not the “unforgivable sin”–providing you are willing to repent and renounce your choise. Yes, it may be hard, but remember that God will be on your side if you choose to follow Him regardless of what a rebellious denomination may say.

  5. In answer to the question posed by Adrian Suarwz, the answer is yes.

    After reading your article, I would highly recommend Divorce and Remarriage in the Church by David Instone-Brewer. Excellent book. (by a Baptist pastor, not a UMC)

    And as a UMC clergy, I am glad my denomination welcomes everyone just as they are … just as you have strong theological positions for what you believe – we have them for the way we believe. I cherish Scripture in every way. I just happen to see a lot more verses on Jesus saying “come to me all who are heavy laden” than verses that deal with divorce. I see Jesus inviting Mathew to be a disciple, going to a tax collector’s home, touching the lepers, teaching women, welcoming children.. and saying “come as you are” … not be shamed and come to me when you finally are perfect.

    • Hello Susan…. Thank you so much for writing and sharing your thoughts.

      Susan, I am glad that you want to read the Bible and encourage others to do so also. However, it is very important that we not only read and encourage others to do so, but it is very, very important that we believe and obey the Scriptures–God’s Word.

      Jesus said, “Heavena nd earth will pass away, but My words will not pass away” (Matthew 24:35). He also declared, “He who rejects Me and does not receive My wayings, has one who judged him; the word I spoke is what will judge him at the last day” (John 12:48). It is important that we actually obey what Jesus said–whether it is about divorce or any other subject.

      The same is true about the remainder of the New Testament. When the apostles and other writers wrote their letters, they meant for their writings to be read and received. Read 1 Thessalonians 2:13 and 1 Corinthians 14:37.

      As for the subject of divorce and remarriage, I am not really sure which original writing on the website you are referring to.I realize that this is a difficult issue for there are many who are in unwanted marriages and want to escape the oppression. But Jesus surely meant what He said when He speaks on this topic (see Matthew 19:2-12 and Marki 10:11-12).

      Other subjects are just as important and unambiguous. For instands, the apostles said that a woman was to keep silent in the assembly of Christians and she was not to teach or exercise authority over the man/male (1 Timothy 2:11-12 and 1 Corinthians 14:33-37). Thus, when Paul says that the men are to pray in public (1 Timothy 2:8) and only men are to be overseers in an assembly (1 timothy 2:11-12 and 1 Corinthians 14:33-35; Titus 1:5-9; 1 Timothy 3:1-8). This is God’s will and we must accept it.

      Let us seek God’s will and believe and obey it just as God revealed this in His Word.

      Thank you again for writing and may God bless you as you continue to seek for His will in all you do.

  6. Now get this . . . my fiance and I were recently thrown out of church because 1) we believe that we were only eligible to get married because neither of us had had a partner before (and we had both waited for the right one for over 40 years); 2) we planned to get married for life; and 3) we believe that “divorce and remarriage” is inexcusable in God’s sight. During marriage counseling, the pastor we had asked to marry us decided that we were legalists because we believed these things. He changed his mind, said he wouldn’t marry us after he had already told us he would, and said that if we refused to eat with other church members who were admittedly in second marriages with previous spouses still living (I Cor. 5:9-13), we were no longer welcome. So we left.

    Great marriage counseling! Absolutely great! Leave that loophole open. And churches often wonder why there are few solid families in their churches. Maybe because they get rid of them?

    • Hello Jane… Thank you so much for sharing these painful experiences with us and informing us of the terrible response by this unscriptural and humanistic pastor.

      Surely this is merely the “tip of the iceberg” in regard to this pastor and the United Methodist Church. From reading God’s Word, I would assume that Paul the apostle himself would not be welcome there.

      Jane, it is important that you not only see the faulty reasoning and unbiblical counsel that you have received, but that you look beyond marriage and divorce to many other subjects. The series in our website on the United Methodist Church will provide many different aspects of Methodism that must be rejected.

      I commend you, Jane, for waiting for marriage and keeping yourself pure before this very, very serious step. I too waited for a very long time before God brought a dear woman into my life. It was a joy to be able to have a marriage/wedding that was God-centered and holy. We have no regrets at all. Actually, as you know, this is the way it is to be done.

      Thus, I recommend that you read the whole article on United Methodism and you will discover that divorce and remarriage is not the only point worth considering. Further, please read other article on the website–for there are now about 2,000 of them. (See http://www.Truediscipleship.com.)

      May God bless you abundantly as you seek God’s will and determine to walk in it (see 1 John 2:17).

  7. Adrian Suarwz says:

    To whom it may concern, can a person pastor under the Methodist Church? After divorce and re-married?,

    • Hello Adrian. Thank you so much for writing and asking this important question. I must admit that I don’t know the answer to this. From the research that I’ve done (as reflected on the series on the United Methodist Church, found on the website that you have seen), it is sufficient to know that there are massive negatives in the United Methodist Church. This would include divorce and remarriage. There must be thousands of members who are presently living in adultery, as defined by our Lord Jesus (see Matthew 5:31-32; 19:3-12; Mark 10:11-12; Luke 16:18; Romans 7:2-3). This should repel us from this denomination, regardless of whether a Methodist pastor has remarried or not.