Responses to: Do You Know WHEN You Were Saved?
8 Comments
Stay Updated
Leave your email to hear about new articles and site news. We won't share your address.
Most Commented
- Our Welcome Page and Guest Book 175 comments
- The Woman's Glory: Comments 60 comments
- Families Divided! Comments 27 comments
- The Truediscipleship Blog 20 comments
- Time Management: Do You Tithe Your Time? Comments 16 comments
- The United Methodist Church: Divorce and Remarriage Comments 14 comments
- Do You Know WHEN You Were Saved? Comments 8 comments
- The Lottery and Powerball Comments 3 comments
Most Viewed
- Official List of Sins (New Testament) 243,819 views
- Agradando a Dios en nuestra manera de vestir 154,335 views
- Was Jesus Actually Naked on the Cross? 54,844 views
- Ten Scriptural Reasons Why the Rock Beat is Evil in Any Form 51,571 views
- How is Baptism Defined by Greek Dictionaries? 49,897 views
- Why I Left the Lutheran Church 49,854 views
- Long Hair–The Woman’s Glory 49,428 views
- Bendiciones Espirituales en Jesucristo 49,114 views
- Families Divided! 38,903 views
- Living for the Lord in a Wicked World 36,706 views
Recent Posts
In Memory of Richard Hollerman
I Still Don’t Understand
In the Beginning
Confusion
How Does God View Them?
The Hamas/Palestinian War
Time Passes
News Channels
News Channels
We Wonder How Much Immorality Can America Stand
Connoquenessing?
Why Did the Southern Border Deal Fail?
Why Did the Southern Border Deal Fail?
When Will the Houthis Understand?
Hollywood and Leading Characters
What Should We Think of Drugs?
For the Muslims against Israel
Terms
Illegal Migrants?
The Wilderness and Fellowship
The Many Disturbances in America
Children are a Gift of the Lord
Gay?
Songs and Singing
Wherever we Look!
Money and Fame
This World has Invaded Us!
Will We Die Young or Old?
Where are They Now?
The Use of Tobacco
Will We Die Young or Old?
Absolute Confusion!
Will We Die Young or Old?
Turmoil around the World!
Politics and the News
Stay Updated
Leave your email to hear about new articles and site news. We won't share your address.
Hi Richard,
Here I am again… I’ve read your reply and I’ve had some very, very hard days… These days I’m wondering about being born again and baptism. About the baptism: I gave this to God and I asked Him to lead me to the right choice. I trust in Him.
So for now, about born again… Your reply makes some things very clear to me. I’ve also read that in church there are a lot of ‘believers’ but not all of them are ‘born again’. I’m wondering if I was one of them. One of the biggest questions I have, is: can a person have the Holy Spirit in him/her without being born again?
This is the reason why I ask that question:
You wrote: “When one comes to Christ (in repentance and faith expressed in baptism), his determination to live for God has changed and His repudiation of sin and self has also changed. But this doesn’t mean that he or she will never commit another sin ”
So, at age 18 I said in public that I choose Jesus (as in: my personal faith and willing to follow Him) and got “baptized”. When I look back at that time, I cannot say that I was born again. I was always in church and I did grow, but I also kept on going on in sin – since there was no (sincere) repentance yet. Between age 18 and age 23 (I’m now 23), I did have wonderful moments with God and I think I can say with assurance that God was working in my heart, leading me into a deeper relationship with Him. I also was one of the worship leaders in church and my gift is writing worship songs, that was definitely not me, but God’s Spirit. I’ve heard from people that there were times during worship where they clearly saw/felt the anointing of God in my worship. But… I did sin (willful) in seasons and my response to sin clearly was not as what is written in 1 John 3:
“No one who is born of God [deliberately, knowingly, and habitually] practices sin, because God’s seed [His principle of life, the essence of His righteous character] remains [permanently] in him [who is born again—who is reborn from above—spiritually transformed, renewed, and set apart for His purpose]; and he [who is born again] cannot habitually [live a life characterized by] sin, because he is born of God and longs to please Him.”
Today I can say – that after my deep repentance experience in August – that this verse applies to my life. My way of seeing sin has changed and I just don’t want to have anything to do with it. With saying that, I think: maybe I was from age 18-23 a believer who did want to follow Jesus and did grow in God, but I became a BORN AGAIN christian last August. That would make sense. But my question again: what about the Holy Spirit? I cannot and will not deny that the Holy Spirit was in me between 18-23. He clearly worked in my life, I simply never broke with my relationship with sin ’till last August.
Could you help me with this one? I hope I’m being clear. So… Can a believer have the Holy Spirit, without being born again yet? Or is the Holy Spirit ONLY given to or living in people who are already born again?
Naomi
NAOMI, THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR WTITING AND EXPRESSING YOURSELF. i RESPONDED TO THIS IN WORD AND THEN COPIED AND PASTED IT BELOW. bUT IT DIDN’T TURN OUT VERY WELL. i COULD SEND IT BETTER IF YOU WERE WILLING TO SEND ME YOUR EMAIL ADDRESS OR SEND YOUR QUESTION BELOW VIA EMAIL. IT WOULD BE MORE LEGIBLE. BUT, IF NOT, YOU MIGHT BE ABLE TO WORK SOME OF THIS OUT AND UNDERSTAND IT.
MmAY GOD BLESS YOU IN THIS IMPORTANT MATTER.
rICHARD
Hi Richard,
Here I am again… I’ve read your reply and I’ve had some very, very hard days… These days I’m wondering about being born again and baptism. About the baptism: I gave this to God and I asked Him to lead me to the right choice. I trust in Him.
Remember that there is a connection here. In baptism, there is new life (Romans 6:3-5) and a spiritual circumcision (Colossians 2:11-13). These sorts of things are related to the new birth/ birth of the Spirit/ birth of water and the Spirit. As you know, the NT writers don’t have a uniform way of expressing themselves. They may say similar things but in a variety of ways, using a variety of expressions. In the first several centuries, it is interesting that most of the writers saw John 3:5 as crucial, expressing “baptism” in the Spirit and in water. I, personally, don’t often make this connection since baptism is not mentioned, per se, in John 3, but it is worth considering. Especially since baptism in water (John’s baptism) is mentioned later, in John 3:23, 26; 4:1-2.
So for now, about born again… Your reply makes some things very clear to me. I’ve also read that in church there are a lot of ‘believers’ but not all of them are ‘born again’. I’m wondering if I was one of them. One of the biggest questions I have, is: can a person have the Holy Spirit in him/her without being born again?
Very good question, Naomi. I have a study I made (actually, a booklet) that really should be on the website. It is entitled something like, “The Paradox of Unbaptized Believers.” It needs to be online. However, it was written and booklet produced before I had a computer. It would take a lot of effort to do this. I could send you a copy if you like. I think that it might help you a lot. Just let me know and send me your mailing address.
This is the reason why I ask that question:
You wrote: “When one comes to Christ (in repentance and faith expressed in baptism), his determination to live for God has changed and His repudiation of sin and self has also changed. But this doesn’t mean that he or she will never commit another sin ”
This is clear from passages like 1 John 1:8-10 and 2:1-2. And, of course, other passages.
So, at age 18 I said in public that I choose Jesus (as in: my personal faith and willing to follow Him) and got “baptized”. When I look back at that time, I cannot say that I was born again. I was always in church and I did grow, but I also kept on going on in sin – since there was no (sincere) repentance yet.
Yes, Romans 6:1-11 is quite important regarding this, Naomi.
Between age 18 and age 23 (I’m now 23), I did have wonderful moments with God and I think I can say with assurance that God was working in my heart, leading me into a deeper relationship with Him. I also was one of the worship leaders in church and my gift is writing worship songs, that was definitely not me, but God’s Spirit. I’ve heard from people that there were times during worship where they clearly saw/felt the anointing of God in my worship. But… I did sin (willful) in seasons and my response to sin clearly was not as what is written in 1 John 3:
“No one who is born of God [deliberately, knowingly, and habitually] practices sin, because God’s seed [His principle of life, the essence of His righteous character] remains [permanently] in him [who is born again—who is reborn from above—spiritually transformed, renewed, and set apart for His purpose]; and he [who is born again] cannot habitually [live a life characterized by] sin, because he is born of God and longs to please Him.”
Today I can say – that after my deep repentance experience in August – that this verse applies to my life.
Naomi, it does take humility to confess that we have failed to do right or that we have done wrong. We need God to help us and show us His will.
My way of seeing sin has changed and I just don’t want to have anything to do with it.
That is so good, Naomi. We do need to abhor sin for it sent Jesus Christ to the cross. And it will send billions of people to hell. It is not to be trifled with, as you know.
With saying that, I think: maybe I was from age 18-23 a believer who did want to follow Jesus and did grow in God, but I became a BORN AGAIN christian last August. That would make sense. But my question again: what about the Holy Spirit? I cannot and will not deny that the Holy Spirit was in me between 18-23. He clearly worked in my life, I simply never broke with my relationship with sin ’till last August.
I thought that I was saved with the Holy Spirit working in my life—for many years. Finally, by God’s conviction through the Spirit and through His Word, I humbled myself and sought God’s will and work. Of course, I was rebaptized (baptized again) genuinely.
If one is not truly saved, he or she doesn’t have the indwelling Spirit inside. The Spirit may work in our heart and life without the Spirit actually indwelling our heart and life. As Jesus said, “He, when He comes, will convict the world concerning sin and righteousness and judgment” (John 16:8; see also vv. 7-15). Another consideration is that the apostles and many devout people did manifest righteousness and obedience, but didn’t truly have the Spirit (see 7:37-39). Also see Acts 19:1-6.
Could you help me with this one? I hope I’m being clear. So… Can a believer have the Holy Spirit, without being born again yet? Or is the Holy Spirit ONLY given to or living in people who are already born again?
It might be better to say that the Spirit is given within the new birth of the Spirit. The Spirit is the one God uses to regenerate us (bring us to the new birth, the spiritual birth. As I’ve said before, it might be good to read such passages as:
Acts 2:38-39
Acts 5:32;
Acts 19:1-6
Romans 6:1-11, especially vv. 3-5
Colossians 2:11-13
Galatians 3:26-27 with 4:6, especially
I hope that these considerations do help and clarify some things, Naomi. May God bless you as you sincerely work these things out. Many have failed to understand such things, but God has given us His Word to lead us in His ways. See Acts 17:11.
May God bless you,
Richard
Naomi
Dear Richard,
I am so sorry for my late reply, I forgot I left a message – but I am so happy to see that you replied so soon! (I am the same person “.”) My name is Naomi… 🙂
You wrote this:
“At this point (since this past August), you think that you are living for Jesus and that you are not deliberately sinning. Is this right? But now you are not sure if you have been truly “born again” or saved. Is this right?”
My answer is this:
Yes, that is right – kind of. I would say I’m saved, yes. I mean I really have a relationship with the Father – I know that I am His Child -, Jesus and the Holy Spirit. It’s just that I’m not that person that once did not know God and now gets to know Him and gets born-again. Because, I’ve always believed in Him and always known Him, always called Him Father. Always went to church, always felt in my heart: He is the truth, I need to follow Him. So when I think about being born-again, it’s hard, because I would say “yes, probably I am” but I cannot say when that happened…
Now about baptism…
What I see in the Bible, is that people believed in Christ and immediately got baptized. If I understand it rightly, these people didn’t wait until they grew in faith, they just got baptized. So then I think, did all of them really break with sin? Sometimes I’m glad to read in the letters to the church (like Corinthians) that some of the believers lived in sin, and they were corrected – I feel like okay, I’m not the only one…
I’ve read your article on baptism, and I can say the following things about myself:
– I have been baptized in the name of the Father, Son and the Holy Spirit.
– After baptism I did a discipleship training in church and there’s also where my fruits became visible; my life, my character changed.
– I DID NOT deeply repent of my sins at the time of my baptism. I think that is the reason why the four years after baptism, I switched between living for God and chasing for sin again. This now stopped, since last August. I even hate the sin I committed after baptism (especially sexual sin).
– I do believe I received the Holy Spirit short after baptism, because I did get a clearer view of what is sin and what is the will of God. Problem was, I always held unto “there is grace” when I sinned. So I sinned and later asked for grace – which is really wrong, since grace is NOT a license for sin. But again: I repented of that too, I even HATE that way of thinking and all I want is to stop sinning and honor God.
– I think I did not really realize back then when I got baptized that I would “die” to sin… I think I just saw it as a statement: “I choose for Christ”. I mean, I knew you should not sin, but I did not saw the seriousness of it. During these four years, I understood it more, and now I totally understand it – I just don’t want to sin… I want to honor God!
– My life after baptism did not change a lot. As I said, I believe short after baptism I received the Holy Spirit, because WHEN I chose to sin, of course I was in conflict and later led to repentance. And I believe that last August the Holy Spirit really woke me up and brought me to deep, deep repentance. Here again I come to the same point: I got baptized, but I didn’t not break with sin, ‘till last August.
I’ve thought about getting baptized again, but I don’t think that’s what God wants – I’ve read/heard somewhere “we should not get baptized for a second time, because we cannot crucify Christ for a second time” and indeed I don’t want to do that!
So then I think… Okay – I did get baptized and my life did change a little after that. My character changed and I did break with sins (like getting drunk, partying, cursing). But with sin in general, I did not break – and so I lived on in sexual sin (when that temptation came) and disobedience, rebelliousness (in seasons)… But – the good thing is that the Holy Spirit clearly lives in me, otherwise I would not feel bad while and after sinning, otherwise I would never repent of it all last August. So what to do know. I don’t know. If God really forgives me of my stupid way of living (wilful sin after baptism) then I think it’s alright between me and Him, right? (On the internet there’s also a lot of arguments about forgiveness after wilful sin.. But I think when we look at the bible, God always wants to forgive and restore and the fact that someone is brought to repentance, that’s the work of the Holy Spirit, right…?)
Sorry, this is such a long message. But it’s something I’m struggling with this daily. I am really sure about the fact that I have a relationship with God and God has a relationship with me. But I don’t to die one day and that God says: “wel… You never really got born again or baptized the right way…”
I really hope you want to reply to me again… Thank You so much.
Naomi
Hi Naomi… I’m so glad that you wrote and expressed yourself so honestly and forthrightly. I’d like to reply with a few comments. I sometimes wonder if I should copy such long posts and comment on them or try to remember. Well, let me try to remember. If I forget some thoughts, please write back and mention something more and I surely will plan to answer further.
As I understand it, 4 years ago you were baptized and you think that you were sincere. However, you were changed a little but went on sinning for some 4 more years, until last August. At that time, you really repented and “died” to sin and are disgusted with those 4 years of compromises. Is that right?
It is important that you see the connection between being born again and being saved. They happen together and are two different ways of looking at the same matter. We do know that Jesus spoke about being born again or born from above (see John 3:3-7; also 1:12-14). And in the same context, the Lord spoke about receiving eternal life (John 3:15-16). He also spoke about being saved (v. 17) and not being judged (v. 18). Jesus said that either we have eternal life or we face the wrath/anger of God (v. 36). Of course, there are a dozen other passages on this but, for now, this probably is sufficient.
As you know, baptism in itself is nothing but getting wet. Thus, the inner meaning of baptism must be there. And in baptism, we repent of our sins (see especially Acts 2:38-39; 3:19) and die to sin (see Colossians 2:12-13 and Romans 6:3-5). Even John’s baptism was a “baptism of repentance” (Mark 1:4; Luke 3:3) for it expressed an inner change, or repentance.
When one comes to Christ (in repentance and faith expressed in baptism), his determination to live for God has changed and His repudiation of sin and self has also changed. But this doesn’t mean that he or she will never commit another sin (this is a false teaching of a few smaller groups). 1 John 1:8-10; 2:1-3 speaks to this.
I think the reference you made about crucifying Christ again is taken from Hebrews 6:4-6. This is a good passage about those who would fall away, but I doubt that it speaks to the issue of being baptized again. We do know that there is one baptism (Ephesians 4:5), but if we discover that our “first” baptism was defective, surely God would want us to be truly baptized again–this time expressing genuine faith and true repentance. As you may remember, 12 men at Ephesians were baptized again (see Acts 19:1-6).
It is important that you not look to a man or group or men or church or denomination to make your choice on such things. God wants you to look to Him and not another human being (see Acts 5:29). We want to please God and not another person (see Galatians 1:10).
I’ll let it go with this, but if you do have further comments or questions, please don’t hesitate to write. Okay? May God bless you abundantly.
I have an important question…
I was born in a Christian family and going to church, praying and reading the bible was always a ‘normal’ thing to do. I have always believed in God, Jesus, the Holy Spirit.
When I was 18 years old I got baptized because I knew this is what you do when you believe. The truth is, back then I’ve never had a “born-again” of “I got saved” experience, I just believed and with getting baptized I wanted to make a statement that I will continue my walk with Christ – not because my parents tell me to do so, but because this is my choice.
Truth is, I never really broke with sin – the result is that I did lots and lots of sinning. I’ve had seasons after baptism where I was really hungry for God and I wanted to be a devoted follower of Jesus. But as soon as temptation came my way (especially sexual temptation), I chose for sin. Later I would ask for forgiveness and start over again with wanting to live for God.
Because I was in the worshipteam, I felt like I was a grown-up christian already. I really did have wonderful moments where I realized that God is the only one I want, but still I was never really steadfast in this.
Last year (4 years after baptism) I came into a hard season and I started (willful) sinning again for months. I broke with that sexual relationship and struggled a lot with “is there still forgiveness for me?” Last august, I experienced a deep repentance – I never repented like this. I started to see ALL the sin (not only sex, but also disobedience, pride, …). I repented and only had one desire: to be forgiven and to have a fresh new start, to really live with and for Christ!
Today I finally believe that I am forgiven for all the sin, I’ve shown true repentance – what can only be led by the Holy Spirit, right? And because of His grace, I am forgiven.
Still, I do struggle with being born again. We can only go to heaven if we are born again, but am I born again? I don’t know a specific time or date where this might have happened. I just always believed, getting older I switched between seasons of devotion and sinning and since last August I sincerely repented and turned away from sin and came back to God.
What does the bible say about this – my story? I see on the internet that a lot of Christians are saying different things. Would you please help me with this question?
God bless you.
Dear friend, thank you so much for writing. (I will call you “friend” since I do not know your name.)
I read your letter and inquiry and do thank you for explaining all of this. I can see that you now regret having done a lot of the things that you were doing over the years. It is good to have such regret. Only you can tell me what was in your heart, thus only you can tell me if you repented. As you know, repentance is a sorrow over our sin and a determination to stop sinning. As Paul wrote, “Stop sinning” (1 Corinthians 15:34).
At this point (since this past August), you think that you are living for Jesus and that you are not deliberately sinning. Is this right? But now you are not sure if you have been truly “born again” or saved. Is this right?
Friend, it may be true that you were “baptized some 4 years ago, but were you truly baptized? As you must know, genuine baptism only happens if we deliberately “die” to sin and begin to live a righteous and true life. (See Romans 6:1-11). We died to sin and are buried with Christ in baptism, from which we rise to live a new life. (See Colossians 2:11-13 and Romans 6:3-5.)
I encourage you to type in “baptize” and “baptism” into the Search feature on my website. http://Www.Truedicipleship.com. This will give you many other articles on baptism and the meaning of this significant act. Also, you should type in Repent and Repentance to determine if you actually repented.
If you came to see Jesus as He is presented in Scripture, if you truly turned away from sin and your self-will, if you trusted in Jesus and His shed blood shed on the cross and also believed in Jesus resurrected. Then you need to trust that God has or will forgive you. the Bible calls this the “new birth” or the “second birth” or being “born again.”
Please consider these things and pray about this. God doesn’t want you to be in confusion and He doesn’t want you to give up. He wants you to be fully forgiven as a “new creature” in Christ (2 Corinthians 5:17). I hope that you will use the website that I mentioned above (see http://www.Truediscipleship.com). This should help very much.
May God bless you abundantly. –Richard
Thank you for a true message-there is a time and place, salvation is a conscious decision-
not unconscious, it is sealed by “calling on the name of the Lord”….and according to
Scripture, is “repentance toward God and faith in the LORD Jesus Christ”. Anything less
is simply not salvation.
Many people, like Paul, have had a confrontation….but unlike Paul, have not followed up
with a conversion (re-Acts 19 & the disciples of John the Baptizer. Sadly, Ruth Graham
died without such a decision and was misled by her husband, who believes that it is not
even necessary to know the name of Jesus and that a salvation experience is not necessary.
(Check out his interview with Robert Schuller-proof of blasphemous heresy). Many Thanks;
One improvement-make you point earlier for those who do not read to the endm, lest they
get the wrong teaching.
David
David, Thank you so much for writing and sharing your thoughts. I certainly agree that Paul had a confrontation (with Jesus appearing to him) and also a conversion. Regarding conversion, we are saying that one must turn from one thing (sin) to another (God and holiness) (1 Thessalonians 1:9-10). As you say, this is the only way to be saved.
Regarding Ruth Graham (a Presbyterian, I believe), are you saying that Ruth followed Billy’s idea that we need not know the name of Jesus to be saved? We both know that this would be wrong. We are saved through the name of Jesus (Acts 4:12). And how could one be saved without knowing the gospel of Christ (Mark 16:15-16)?
Now that you mention Robert, I believe that I do remember seeing a video in which Billy said one may be saved without knowing the gospel of Jesus Christ. Perhaps the video you mention is the one I’ve seen. This would definitely be a wrong belief! How can one be saved without a true faith in the person and saving work of Jesus Christ? There are dozens of passages that would say the opposite (cf. John 3:14-18, 36; 5:24; 6:47; 11:25-26; 20:28-30). We do know that Jesus is the way, the truth, and the life (John 14:6) and we must believe this in order to receive eternal life.
Your statement that one should bring up the point of an article before stating it at the conclusion, is well taken. Thank you for your comments. I hope that you continue to read the articles on Truediscipleship.com.